Get Stronger in 3 minutes (or less)

World records, results, training, nutrition, breaking news, and more. Join the BarBend Newsletter for everything you need to get stronger. Join the BarBend Newsletter for workouts, diets, breaking news and more.
BarBend Newsletter

Pull-Up Challenge: Strongman Brian Shaw Vs. A Navy SEAL

Do you think the four-time World's Strongest Man can beat a Navy SEAL in a pull-up challenge?

Pull-ups are one of the most challenging bodyweight movements to master, but if you’re a four-time winner of the World’s Strongest Man, a pull-up challenge is just another day in the life, right?

Strongman Brian Shaw decided to put his bodyweight strength to the test with former Navy SEAL, Sean Rosario, in a series of four events. 

  • Event 1: Grip Challenge
  • Event 2: 500-Meter Row for Speed
  • Event 3: Max Pull-Ups
  • Event 4: Cold Tub Challenge

The first event Shaw and Rosario went head-to-head in what was called “the grip challenge.” This was a test to determine overall grip strength. At 2:30 in the video, you can see them begin the grip challenge — and after a very close first event — Shaw picked up the win.

For the second challenge, Shaw and Rosario took on a 500 meter row for speed, which Shaw titled the “Rower Challenge.” Shaw picked up the second event’s win with a time of 1:14. Rosario finished with 1:33.8. Shaw’s rowing challenge win might seem like a surprise to some, but remember, Shaw almost broke the 100-meter Concept 2 World Record just last year, so he’s proven he can row quickly!

The third event was the pull-up challenge and Shaw managed to complete six reps, but Rosario took home this round completing 20-reps.

Pull-up strength in general is the ultimate movement to increase upper body strength and muscle growth. While we wouldn’t categorize Shaw as a beginner in the pull-up field, it is not an easy movement for someone who sits around 400 pounds.

The final competition was a “cold tub challenge”, which was used to see who could last the longest in a cold tub — an activity both professional athletes and Navy SEALs are usually accustomed to. With very little movement, and from what on the outside looked like just two guys hanging out in a jacuzzi, the event ended in a draw. Something tells us this cold tub challenge was really just a way for these two to ice their muscles after three strenuous challenges.

So, despite Shaw winning the day of challenges going 2-1-1 against Rosario, when it comes to pull-ups, it appears the navy seal had the edge over the professional strongman.

Feature image from SHAWSTRENGTH Youtube channel.

Leave a Comment