• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
The BarBend Logo in white.

BarBend

The Online Home for Strength Sports

  • Strength
    • Best Home Gym Machines
      • Best Functional Trainers
      • Best Squat Racks
      • Best Budget Home Gym Equipment
      • Best Cable Machines
      • Best Weight Benches
      • Best Smith Machines
      • Best Smart Home Gyms
    • Best Barbells
      • Best Budget Exercise Bikes
      • Best Budget Barbells
      • Best Powerlifting Barbells
      • Best Barbells For Women
    • Best Kettlebells
      • Best Adjustable Kettlebells
    • Best Dumbbells
      • Best Adjustable Dumbbells
    • More Strength Equipement
      • Best Resistance Bands
      • Best Weight Plates
      • Best Bumper Plates
      • Best Slam Balls
      • Best Weighted Vests
      • Best Weight Sleds
      • All Other Strength Equipment
    • Training
      • Exercise Guides
        • Deadlift
        • Bench Press
        • Back Squat
        • Overhead Press
        • Lat Pulldown
        • Shoulder Exercises
        • Chest Exercises
        • Ab Exercises
        • Quad Exercises
        • Biceps Exercises
      • Training Guides
        • Beginner’s Guide to the Gym
        • How to Build Muscle
        • Guide to Muscle Hypertrophy
        • How to Train on a Cut
      • Workouts
        • Back Workouts
        • At-Home Workouts
        • Chest & Back Workouts
        • Full-Body Workout
        • HIIT Workouts
        • Bodybuilding Workouts
        • Farmer’s Carry Workouts
      • Programs
        • 5×5 Program
        • Bodybuilding Programs
        • Push-Up Program
        • Pull-Up Program
        • 5/3/1 Program
        • Powerbuilding Program
        • German Volume Training
        • Build Your Own Program
    • News
      • CrossFit
      • Strongman
      • Bodybuilding
      • Powerlifting
      • Weightlifting
      • HYROX
    • Individual Strength Equipment Reviews
  • Nutrition
    • Best Pre-Workouts
      • Best Non-Stim Pre-Workouts
      • Best Pre-Workout for Women
      • Best Pre-Workouts for Men
      • Strongest Pre-Workouts
    • Best Protein
      • Best Protein Powder for Men
      • Best Whey Isolate Protein Powders
      • Best Protein Powder For Women
      • Best Tasting Protein Powders
      • Best Protein Bars
      • Protein by Goal
        • Best Mass Gainer
        • Best Protein Powder for Weight Loss
        • Best Protein Powder for Weight Gain
        • Best Protein Powder for Muscle Gain
      • Protein by Diet
        • Best Egg White Protein Powder
        • Best Keto Protein Powder
        • Best Organic Protein Powder
        • Best Vegan Protein Powders
    • Best Creatine
      • Best Creatine Gummies
      • Best Creatine For Women
      • Best Creatine for Men
    • Best BCAA’s
      • Best BCAA’s for Women
    • Best Fat Burners
      • Best Fat Burners For Women
      • Best Non-Stim Fat Burners
      • Best Fat Burners For Men
    • Other Nutrition Products
      • Best Meal Replacements
      • Best Nitric Oxide Supplements
      • Best Electrolyte Supplements
      • Best Greens Powder
        • Best Greens Powder for Pregnancy
      • Best Meal Delivery Services
        • Best Budget Meal Delivery Services
        • Best Vegan Meal Delivery Service
        • Best Healthy Meal Delivery Service
        • Best Meal Delivery Service for Weight Loss
        • Best Paleo Meal Delivery Services
        • Best Multivitamins for Women
        • Best Multivitamins for Men
        • Best Supplement Stacks
        • Best Multivitamins
    • Guides
      • Diets
        • Carb Cycling
        • Vertical Diet
        • Reverse Dieting
        • Carnivore Diet
        • Ketogenic Diet
        • Intermittent Fasting
        • IIFYM Diet
      • Muscle Gain
        • How to Dirty Bulk
        • Go From Cutting to Bulking
        • Eat These Carbs
        • How to Eat for Muscle
      • Fat Loss
        • Macros for Fat Loss
        • Calorie Deficits
        • Natural Fat Burners
        • Cut 2 Pounds Weekly
      • Supplement Guides
        • Pre-Workout
        • Whey Protein
        • Mass Gainers
        • Greens Powders
        • Creatine
        • BCAAs
      • Daily Protein Needs
      • Pre- and Post-Workout Nutrition
      • Foods With Creatine
      • Bulking Tips
    • Individual Supplement Reviews
  • Conditioning
    • Best Treadmills
      • Best Manual Treadmills
      • Best Compact Treadmills
      • Best Budget Treadmills
      • Best Treadmills Under $2000
      • Best Treadmills Under $1000
      • Best Treadmills For Tall People
      • Best Commercial Treadmills
      • Best Curved Treadmills
      • Best Under Desk Treadmills
    • Best Rowing Machines
      • Best Water Rowing Machines
      • Best Budget Rowing Machines
      • Best Compact Rowing Machines
      • Best Foldable Rowing Machines
      • Best Air Rowing Machines
    • Best Exercise Bikes
      • Best Recumbent Bikes
      • Best Folding Exercise Bikes
      • Best Exercise Bikes For Seniors
      • Best Air Bikes
    • Best Ellipticals
      • Best Budget Ellipticals
      • Best Compact Ellipticals
      • Best Rear Driving Ellipticals
      • Best Ellipticals For Seniors
      • Best Under Desk Ellipticals
      • Best Ellipticals Under $1000
    • Other Conditioning Products
      • Best Jump Ropes
      • Best Plyometric Boxes
      • Best Speed Sleds
      • Best Agility Ladders
      • Best Vertical Climbers
      • Best Commercial Stair Climbers
      • Best Affordable Stair Climbers
    • Individual Cardio Equipment Reviews
  • Recovery
    • Best Cold Plunges
    • Best Saunas
      • Best Infrared Sauna
    • Best Massage Guns
      • Best Mini-Massage Guns
    • Best Compression Boots
    • Best Back Massagers
    • Best Massage Chairs
    • Other Recovery Tools
      • Best Inversion Tables
      • Best Vibrating Massage Rollers
      • Best Massage Balls
      • Best Ice Wraps
      • Best Foam Rollers
    • Recovery Guides
  • Fitness Accessories
    • Fitness Tech
      • Best Fitness Apps
        • Best Weightlifting Apps
        • Best Workout Programs
        • Best Cycling Apps
        • Best Treadmills Apps
        • Best Workout Streaming Services
        • Best Workout Apps
        • Best Running Apps
    • Best Bluetooth Earbuds
    • Best Digital Scales
      • Best Smart Scales
    • Best Fitness Trackers
      • Best Heart Rate Monitors
      • Best Pedometers
      • Best Stopwatches
    • Apparel
      • Best Running Shoes
      • Best Weightlifting Shoes
      • Best Cross Training Shoes
      • Best Gym Shorts
      • Best Sports Bras
      • Best Trail Running Shoes
    • Support Gear
      • Best Lifting Straps
      • Best Gym Bags
      • Best Lifting Gloves
      • Best Wrist Wraps
      • Best Lifting Chalk
      • Best Dip Belts
      • Best Pull Up Assist Bands
      • Best Lifting Belts
  • Community Forum
Home » Training Guides » Op-Ed: When Research Comes Up Short In the Gym

Op-Ed: When Research Comes Up Short In the Gym

Research can be a great tool for predicting outcomes, but it shouldn't be an end all be all.

Written by Ben Pollack, Ph.D
Last updated on July 14th, 2023

Editor’s note: This article is an op-ed. The views expressed herein and in the video are the author’s and don’t necessarily reflect the views of BarBend. Claims, assertions, opinions, and quotes have been sourced exclusively by the author.

Lately, I’ve been receiving a lot of requests for supporting my recommendations with “evidence.” I put the word in quotes because usually, when lifters ask for evidence, they specifically mean formal evidence – that is, evidence collected during controlled experiments in an academic setting. There’s certainly nothing wrong with academic research: it’s incredibly useful for supporting hypotheses about how the human body responds to training.

But there are a lot of problems with relying solely on academic research. I addressed this question a bit in a previous article and video here on BarBend, so I don’t want to rehash that too much. I do, however, want to offer a brief summary of the pitfalls between controlled experiments and actual in-the-trenches training:

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by IFBB Pro Dr. Ben Pollack (@phdeadlift)

Potential Pitfalls In Controlled Research

  • Experiments are rarely conducted with highly-trained participants, and therefore may not be applicable to highly-trained athletes.
  • In my opinion, individual variance is such an important factor in training outcomes that even if an experiment’s sample is indicative of the larger population, it may not be applicable to you as an individual. 
  • Academics often face conflicts of interest in the publishing process, which can lead to conclusions not necessarily supported by evidence anyway.

There’s another reason I really dislike an over-reliance on academic research, and that reason deals with the difference between tacit and formal knowledge. Formal knowledge is what we’ve addressed so far: it’s information that has been studied, written down, and applied in a wide variety of settings.

Tacit knowledge isn’t quite the opposite of formal knowledge. In fact, tacit knowledge is usually supported by evidence just like formal knowledge. Tacit knowledge usually gets reviewed, too, by top experts. However, none of this occurs in a strictly controlled, academic setting. That’s because tacit knowledge can’t really be written down or even explained, even by the experts. Instead, it’s communicated primarily through observation and practice.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by IFBB Pro Dr. Ben Pollack (@phdeadlift)

Here’s an example of tacit knowledge: let’s say you’re a strength coach, and you’ve been watching one of your athletes squat. There’s something a bit off with his technique (perhaps he’s leaning forward too much, but still using an appropriate amount of hip drive and not performing a “squat-morning”). You can’t put a name or label on the technique flaw, but you can tell – just by looking at the movement pattern – that this individual athlete needs to narrow his stance a bit and focus more on forward knee displacement. There’s no study that supports that recommendation. Instead, you’re applying your tacit knowledge and experience from your training as a coach to solve the problem.

Now, keep in mind that tacit knowledge can be bastardized just as easily as formal knowledge (maybe more easily). I’m not saying to take everything you hear from a top-level athlete or coach or Internet gurus at face value.In fact, that’s a terrible, terrible, terrible idea.

I am saying that if you spend hours, even days, in search of the scientific evidence that will help you create the perfect program; or if you blindly cling to the evidence that you do find; or if you ignore arguments only for a lack of formal evidence: you need to stop. Instead, I’d suggest you follow these steps.

Four Steps to Using Academic Research Appropriately

1. Stop Obsessing

Seriously. Again, if you’re the guy always looking for scraps of academic research to justify every single thing you do in the gym, you need to stop.  For one, that’s a waste of time and energy. But more importantly, if you base all of your decisions on academic research, you will be setting yourself up for failure – or at least for suboptimal results. 

There’s simply too much value in tacit strength and conditioning knowledge to ignore it completely.

Evidence Based Training
Photo By Rawpixel.com / Shutterstock

2. Make a List

Sit down with your training journal (you do keep a training journal, right?). Go through it – carefully – and select your three, absolute best training cycles. 

Make a list of the common factors among those training cycles. You might pay attention to movement selection, loading parameters, and even significant life events outside of the gym.  

3. Check it Twice

After you’ve made your list, put it aside for a few days to allow your mind to clear. Then, go back through it, and this time, try to identify which of the “success factors” you are still using in your current training. If you’ve dropped any of them, ask yourself why you might have deviated from a method that was working!

4. Iterate and Experiment

Now that you know your success factors and how they fit into the scheme of your current training methods, try to identify new methods that might further improve your training.  For example, if you found that all of your training cycles involve safety-bar squats, you might brainstorm other movements that share elements in common with the safety bar.

Applying the Research…

Now, here’s where academic studies can be valuable. Let’s say you’ve found that all of your successful training cycles involve traditional periodization blocks (hypertrophy, strength, etc.), but you’ve grown bored with that method. 

It might be a good time to investigate daily undulating periodization, and use the research to develop a plan to transition from “traditional” block periodization to DUP.

Feature image from @phdeadlift Instagram page. 

About Ben Pollack, Ph.D

Ben Pollack is a professional powerlifter and holds the all-time world record raw total of 2039 in the 198-pound class. He has won best overall lifter at the largest raw meets in the world, including the US Open, Boss of Bosses, and Reebok Record Breakers.

View All Articles

Primary Sidebar

Latest Reviews

Featured image for the Ironmaster Super Bench Pro V2 Review

Ironmaster Super Bench Pro V2 Review (2025): Our Expert’s New Favorite FID Bench

Titan T3 Power Rack Review

Titan T3 Power Rack Review (2025): An Expert-Approved Rig Beckoning to Budget-Minded Athletes

Our tester works out at the beach in preparation for the Rogue Resistance Bands Review

Rogue Resistance Bands Review (2025): Tested by a Certified Personal Trainer

Barbend tester Jake Herod works out on a Force USA Trainer

Force USA G3 Review (2025): Our Experts Tested This Compact All-In-One Rack for Small Home Gyms

BarBend

BarBend is an independent website. The views expressed on this site may come from individual contributors and do not necessarily reflect the view of BarBend or any other organization. BarBend is the Official Media Partner of USA Weightlifting.

  • About Us
  • Advertise With Us
  • Contact Us
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Pinterest

Sections

  • CrossFit
  • Strongman
  • Bodybuilding
  • Powerlifting
  • Weightlifting
  • Reviews
  • Nutrition
  • Training

More

  • BarBend Newsletter
  • BarBend Podcast
  • The Ripped Report
  • 1RM Calculator
  • BMR Calculator
  • Macros Calculator
  • Protein Calculator
  • Squat Calculator

Policies

  • Accessibility
  • Advice Disclaimer
  • Cookies Policy
  • Disclaimers
  • Disclosures
  • Editorial Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

Copyright © 2025 · BarBend Inc · Sitemap