“Protein in an hour,
Strengthen thy power.
No gains are made.”
This might as well be carved in stone at the exit of every gym in the world. The race to gulp down a protein shake within one hour of training is a worldwide phenomenon. I’m willing to bet that you, and everybody you train with, pound a protein shake as soon as you’re done lifting heavy things.
Have you ever questioned whether it makes a real difference in your strength and size?
Nutrient Timing & The “Anabolic Window”
The concept of nutrient timing has been around for ages, but it was largely popularized in 2004 by Dr. Robert Portman & John Ivy in their book, “Nutrient Timing: The Future of Sports Nutrition”.
In case you’ve been living under a rock in the 21st century, nutrient timing is the art and science of eating the correct quantity of protein, carb, and fat at the right time before, during and after your training.
The main goals of nutrient timing, are to:
- Decrease muscle protein breakdown.
- Increase muscle protein synthesis.
- Replenish glycogen (stored carbohydrate).
- Switch from catabolic to anabolic hormone mix (usually via insulin).
The authors of Nutrient Timing deemed the immediate post-workout period the “anabolic phase”. The book cited numerous studies showing that, by consuming the correct quantities of protein and carbohydrate immediately post-workout, an athlete could significantly improve strength, size, performance, and recovery. The studies also showed that delaying nutrient intake could have adverse effects.
The Problem With Nutrient Timing Research
The problem that we run into with nutrient timing research is that much of it is done using endurance athletes performing power tests on recumbent bikes. Functional fitness athletes move large loads, fast. So it is important to only consider research that looks at nutrient timing for study participants who are following a resistance training protocol.
The other issue with much of the research that looks at the effects of nutrient timing is that it looks only at the short-term effects of the supplement protocol. Recently, more studies have been conducted that look at the effects of nutrient timing on study participants following a 10-week periodized program, which is where we can draw the most practical insights.
With that said, let’s take a look at what research can tell us about the one-hour anabolic window of gains.
Is There A Post-Workout Anabolic Window?
The issue is that some of these studies are difficult to apply to an experienced strength athlete because:
- The study didn’t involve resistance exercise.
- The subjects were often untrained and/or elderly.
- The control group consumed less protein throughout the day than the experimental group.
- The studies didn’t look at the effect of timing over the course of a full training cycle.
Studies have shown the availability of amino acids after resistance exercise has a greater effect on maximizing muscle protein synthesis than carbohydrates or placebo alone.
This, however, does not mean that the amino acids have to be consumed immediately after exercise. Due to digestion rates, a meal consumed hours before a training session can still provide the amino acids necessary to initiate post-workout muscle protein synthesis.
What About Insulin?
The consumption of whey protein, carbohydrates, or even a mixed meal after a workout has been shown to elevate insulin levels well above baseline.
“Spiking” insulin is one of the reasons people consume a protein shake post-workout. It is shown to decrease muscle protein breakdown by up to half! This is a very good reason to consume a protein shake and eat a meal post-workout.
Again, this doesn’t necessarily mean that the shake has to be consumed in the one-hour window after training. Insulin levels would stay elevated after training even if you consumed the shake before or during your training session, giving you enough time to get home and eat a whole food meal.
Is Pre-Workout the New Post-Workout?
Some studies show amino acids and carbohydrate consumed prior to exercise do a better job of inducing an anabolic response in muscle than the same supplement consumed after exercise. One study showed that 20g of whey protein delivered pre-workout increased amino acid uptake by the muscles during and up to 3 hours after the training session.
In a very recent, and beautifully designed study, Brad Schoenfeld and colleagues showed that supplementation of 25g of protein with 1g of carbohydrate before resistance training had the same effect on muscle thickness, body composition AND maximal strength.
One of the best studies for those of us who care about moving more weight, faster was done by Cribb & Hayes. The study was one of the first to look at whether the acute effects of nutrient timing were significant over the course of a 10-week weight training cycle.
The study compared the effect of a roughly 34g carbohydrate, 32g whey protein, and 5.6g creatine supplement taken immediately pre- and post-resistance training versus the same supplementation taken at least 5-hours before and after training. The group who consumed the supplement immediately before and after their workout gained significantly more lean mass and strength, while also losing body fat.
Don’t Quit Your Protein Shake…
As you have probably gathered, the jury is still out about whether or not consuming a shake within one hour AFTER training actually provides any real advantages when it comes to muscle strength, size, and performance.
Based on the research that is relevant to strength athletes, it is apparent that consuming protein and carbohydrates around your training session will lead to positive adaptations in the long run. If a protein shake immediately post-workout is already a part of your routine, there is no reason to stop. It is certainly not hurting you.
One lesson you can take away from this research is not to neglect your pre-workout nutrition just because the post-workout window has been put on a pedestal. There is plenty of evidence that sandwiching your workout with protein, carbohydrate, and even creatine is worth your while.
Ivy, John, and Robert Portman. Nutrient timing: the future of sports nutrition. North Bergen, NJ: Basic Health Publications, 2004.
Aragon, Alan, and Brad Schoenfeld. “Nutrient Timing Revisited.” Functional Foods, 2013, 65-89. doi:10.1201/b16307-5.
Editors note: This article is an op-ed. The views expressed herein are the authors and don’t necessarily reflect the views of BarBend. Claims, assertions, opinions, and quotes have been sourced exclusively by the author.